Aug 17, 2017 hemingway went on record as saying that the breaking point was his favorite of all the films that had anything to do with his books or short stories, and one suspects that relative faithfulness to. The book is full of this sort of literary psychoanalysis, and while at. The breaking point, hemingway, dos passos and the murder of jose robles, by stephen koch, robson books, 2006. Hemingways feast on the move into new edition wbur news. The breaking point is a 1950 american film noir crime drama directed by michael curtiz and the second film adaptation of the 1937 ernest hemingway novel to have and have not. Both a biographical portrait and historyinminiature, the breaking point explores the time ernest hemingway and john dos passos shared in the spanish civil war. Breaking point is a 2002 young adult novel by alex flinn. Her parents are constantly fighting, and her troubled little brother is out of control. What happened between hemingway and dos passos in spain is the subject of stephen kochs new book, the breaking point. The breaking point is an interesting and wellwritten book, for two reasons.
One of the last films john garfield made while under attack by the political predators of the house unamerican activities committee, the breaking point is a hardedged film noir with a slight subversive streak. The breaking point is a fascinating multilayered narrative that explores russian scheming and influence in spanish civil war, the presence of stalinist agents in americas cultural scene in the 1930s, the creative and personal turmoil of hemingway, and the fading career dos passos. The breaking point book pima county public library. So what went wrong between ernest hemingway and john dos passos, the two most famous writers of their generation. As told to john garfields daughter by patricia neal, this was the only hemingway adaptation. Hemingway, dos passos, and the murder of jose robles 9781582432816 by koch, stephen and a great selection of similar new, used and collectible books available now at great prices. If the reader had a dislike for hemingway before kochs portrayal of the crucial event, afterward, he or she will find him utterly contemptible. Provides an account of how ernest hemingway and john dos passos, the new literary voices of america, traveled to spain together during the spanish civil war, and how their relationship and rivalry reached a critical point after the murder of a close friend who was accused as a spy. Aug 23, 2017 that would be the breaking point, the 1950 movie based on the same hemingway book. Its an important historical analysis of the spanish civil war, but made in the context of the profoundly conflicted friendship of two american literary giants. Bulletin for the center for childrens books said that the book was a dark drama of selfdestruction that should make for grimly satisfying reading while voice of youth advocates called its characters brilliantly twisted. However, for hem, the war was an intense experience necessary for renewing his artistic and emotional health, and thus he could. Its not a great film, but its an effecting and often powerful piece of cinema that benefits greatly from both john garfields sterling lead performance and michael curtizs assured and imaginative direction. This hemingway summer allows me the opportunity to give a quick plug to a great book on hemingway that came out a few years ago.
It is also the most well written portion, as it rises to the emotional drama of a suspense novel. Hemingway, dos passos, and the murder of jose robles 9781582432816. Do not miss michael curtiz devastating romancenoir the breaking point, playing at the stanford on sept. Once an honor student, vicky is quickly falling behind in her classes at.
When american authors john dos passos and ernest hemingway went to spain in 1937 to witness the spanish civil war firsthand, the. So he is tempted by an illegal run for some big money. Breaking point is an excellent political and literary biography. The breaking point is literary and political history that belongs alongside homage to catalonia and the best biographies of hemingway and dos passos. Order now from when american authors john dos passos and ernest hemingway went to spain in 1937 to witness the spanish civil war firsthand, the devastation they. Here was have john garfield playing with great realism a boating man, morgan, who has hit hard times. The spanish civil war served as a crucible on which many relationships between people and between people. Aug 10, 2017 as snappy as the performances and dialogue are in that film, the breaking point adapts hemingways book and wrings out some genuine notes of solid tragedy, as well as a more nuanced performance from its lead actor. Hemingway and dos passos in the middle of the 1930 were americas two leading novelists. Past, present, and future collide to throw respected forensic anthropologist bill brocktons successful, secure life into devastating turmoil in this poignant novel in the new york times bestselling body farm mystery series its been ten years since dr. Hemingway was a political naif who had neither the time nor inclination to question stalins and the cominterns murderous intrigues in spain.
Although kochs breaking point focuses on the relationship between dos passos and hemingway and dos passos and robles the story also paints a broader picture of a time and place where many intellectuals and artists literary or otherwise on the left had to face an apparent conflict between their personal sense of morality and the socio. Jul, 2009 this hemingway summer allows me the opportunity to give a quick plug to a great book on hemingway that came out a few years ago. Apr 17, 2005 the breaking point hemingway, dos passos, and the murder of jose robles. The breaking point by michael curtiz john garfield, phyllis. The breaking point, a noirish 1950 hemingway adaptation, received a deluxe dvdbluray release this month, courtesy the criterion collection.
Hollywoods second version of hemingway s minor novel to have and have not turns out to be a spanking good adventure story, ranging from california to mexico and exploiting the. That i cant judge as i havent read it, but when hawks told hemingway he would make a great movie out of his worst novel, he did. Fishing boat captain harry john garfield, ducking hustler duncan wallace ford, finds first the girlfriend patricia neal, then his fare ralph dummke, in a mexican bar, in the breaking point, 1952, from hemingways to be or not to be. Breaking point, the 1952 movie clip sporting blood. Dos worked tirelessly to convince others, including hemingway, of the shifting shades of treachery. He would lose both friends during the spanish civil war.
Stephen koch presents a complex book, in part a biographical study of the personal relationship between ernest hemingway and john dos passos, in part a political analysis of the spanish civil. Jan 31, 2008 the breaking point, hemingway, dos passos and the murder of jose robles, by stephen koch, robson books, 2006. Those three come together, sort of, in an odd but interesting story of the 1930s major literary lights by stephen koch titled the breaking point. The breaking point is the hemingway adaptation you dont. Hemingway s public ridicule of dos passos is the climax of the book.
Hemingway, dos passos, and the murder of jose robles 9781582432809. This film is based on ernest hemingways to have and have not, which was also adapted in 1944 directed by howard hawks and 1958 directed by don siegel. That would be the breaking point, the 1950 movie based on the same hemingway book. Hemingway, dos passos, and the murder of jose robles by stephen koch new york.
Stephen koch presents a complex book, in part a biographical study of the personal relationship between ernest hemingway and john dos passos, in part a political analysis of the spanish civil war, focusing on the role of the soviet union. Hemingway, dos passos and the murder of jose robles. The breaking point npr coverage of the breaking point. It stars john garfield in his secondtolast film role before his death and patricia neal. Hemingway, dos passos, and the murder of jose robles by stephen koch. Hemingway, dos passos, and the murder of jose robles is stephen kochs excellent examination of the destruction of the friendship between american writers ernest hemingway and john dos passos during the spanish civil war. But a reallife literary mystery unfolded when dos passos friend jose roblesa spanishborn johns hopkins professordisappeared. The breaking point by stephen koch sheds light, not only on papas. Stephen koch when john dos passos walked into ernest hemingways room in the florida hotel in madrid, the air was thick with tension. Normal harry is an upstanding model citizen, but once he lets his guard down, it gives way to other vices.
His economical and understated stylewhich he termed the iceberg theory had a strong influence on 20thcentury fiction, while his adventurous lifestyle and his public image brought him admiration from later generations. Its also more faithful to the novel, even though it still takes its own liberties, trading cuba for mexico and florida for. The title alone spark my interest, but i am not a fan of murder mysteries. The breaking point was directed by michael curtiz from a screenplay by ranald macdougall. When i was given the breaking point, as a birthday present, i approached the book with a mixture of excitement and apprehension.
The breaking point adapts hemingways book and wrings out some genuine notes of solid tragedy, as well as a more nuanced performance from its lead actor. New to the criterion collection, this one stars john garfield as a charter boat captain who grows less morally. In many respects hemingway fit lenins definition of a useful idiot to a t. The earlier 1944 film starred humphrey bogart and lauren bacall. Not sure the same can be said of curtiz, although this is a perfectly fine picture. When john dos passos walked into ernest hemingways room in the. The breaking point hemingway, dos passos, and the murder of jose robles. As snappy as the performances and dialogue are in that film, the breaking point adapts hemingways book and wrings out some genuine notes of solid tragedy, as well as a more nuanced performance from its lead actor.
The breaking point by michael curtiz john garfield. Written from a novelists eye for detail, the breaking point is the story of two lives at the intersection of friendship and murder, of love and death, and of literature and history. But the technically most faithful version of hemingways original seagoing adventure is michael curtiz 1950 the breaking point. The breaking point 1950 the breaking point 1950 user. The breaking point 1950 forget for a second that this is a hemingway story, or that it was more famously and loosely made into a movie to have and have not with bogart and bacall in 1944. Michael curtiz and the breaking point hd, 10 minutes filmmakers tony zhou and taylor ramos dissect the films domestic scenes which dont appear in hemingways novel and examine how curtizs threedimensional style of staging and use of reversals heighten tension, establish relationships, and influence the.
An interesting film in its own right, its also part of the very entertaining cinematic afterlife of hemingways allegedly worst novel which is not his worst novel. Hemingway, dos passos, and the murder of jose robles. In fact, his treatment is so cinematic hollywood could easily film the book without much alteration. Ernest miller hemingway july 21, 1899 july 2, 1961 was an american journalist, novelist, shortstory writer, and sportsman. Along the way koch also get a bit lost in the biographical study of two of hemingways marriages. Bill brockton created the body farmthe worlds first postmortem research facility dedicated to advancing the frontiers of. Hollywoods second version of hemingways minor novel to have and have not turns out to be a spanking good adventure story, ranging from. Mar 01, 2006 the breaking point paperback hemingway, dos passos, and the murder of jose robles. The breaking point hemingway, dos passos, and the murder of jose robles book. An otherwise moral captain of a charter boat becomes financially strapped and is drawn into illegal activities in order to keep up payments on his boat.
Hemingway went on record as saying that the breaking point was his favorite of all the films that had anything to do with his books or short stories, and one suspects that relative faithfulness to. Harrys willingness to engage in criminal activities, even out of necessity, affects other areas of his life. His economical and understated stylewhich he termed the iceberg theoryhad a strong influence on 20thcentury fiction, while his adventurous lifestyle and his public image brought him admiration from later generations. In the breaking point he contrasts effectively the highliving of hemingway in the hotel floridata with the dank cellars of the kgb. Hemingway, dos passos, and the murder of jose robles counterpoint.
With john garfield, patricia neal, phyllis thaxter, juano hernandez. Sep 20, 2017 do not miss michael curtiz devastating romancenoir the breaking point, playing at the stanford on sept. A nice guy in noirland reaches the breaking point popmatters. It was a quick pick for reluctant young adult readers in 2003. The breaking point paperback hemingway, dos passos, and the murder of jose robles. Breaking point follows the story of vicky fallon, a bluford sophomore who appears in brothers in arms and the fallen. Hemingway, dos passos and the murder of jose robles by steven koch counterpoint press, 320 pp. An interesting film in its own right, its also part of the very entertaining cinematic afterlife of hemingways allegedly worst novel which is. Key to the breaking points theme is the nature of corruption. Hemingways public ridicule of dos passos is the climax of the book. The breaking point is good and apparently truer to hemingways book. Truer to its ernest hemingway source than the previous film version, the breaking point is a sadly neglected little gem that deserves to be wider known.
649 911 515 625 132 731 733 194 428 350 1028 710 1283 516 871 610 1399 1358 1277 922 1176 571 1355 1356 1414 46 990 377 371 361 1196 752 1205 1121 1128 1357 299